Did Violet Evergarden Die?

by

Violet Evergarden’s poignant story of learning empathy and recovering from the trauma of war has captivated anime fans. But her fate remains ambiguous, leaving many wondering – did Violet Evergarden die?

Introduction: The Enigmatic Ending That Sparked Questions

The ending of the Violet Evergarden anime and movie hint at Violet’s death without explicitly confirming it. This has led to intense speculation among fans about what really happened to Violet and whether she passed away.

Understanding the clues requires examining both the anime timeline and the movie’s future era. Let’s break down the evidence around Violet’s fate step-by-step.

The Anime Leaves Violet’s Future Open

In the anime series finale, Violet is alive and looking forward to reuniting with Major Gilbert, who she believes will return from the war. The story closes on a bittersweet note, with Violet continuing her life and work as an Auto Memory Doll while waiting for Gilbert.

Her ultimate fate remains ambiguous, leaving fans to ponder if they eventually reunited or if Violet lived the rest of her life without seeing Gilbert again. However, there are no direct implications of her death.

The Movie Offers More Cryptic Clues

The Violet Evergarden movie stirs up the question again by jumping 60 years into the future. This era is referred to as “the time without Violet” and a world where Auto Memory Dolls no longer exist.

While Violet’s death isn’t stated, the movie’s narrative style implies she passed away before this future period. But how did she die, and when? Let’s analyze the clues.

Also Read:

Examining the Evidence: Does It Point to Violet’s Death?

Speculation over whether Violet died stems from various hints scattered throughout the movie’s future timeline. Here are the main facts fueling the theories:

“The Time Without Violet”

The very title given to the future era offers a major clue. Referring to it as “the time without Violet” heavily implies she is no longer alive during this period.

Of course, it could mean she simply retired or disappeared from public life. But paired with the other hints, it strongly suggests she passed away sometime before this future era.

The Disappearance of Auto Memory Dolls

In the movie’s future scenes, Auto Memory Dolls no longer exist. Violet was instrumental in pioneering the profession of turning emotions into written letters. She even opened her own Auto Memory Doll service.

So what happened to the industry she helped build? The dolls’ absence in the future era intimates that Violet is no longer around.

Gilbert’s Grandson

A boy named Aidan appears in the future timeline. He is the grandson of Major Gilbert, revealed through his memories of Gilbert.

Aidan’s existence means Gilbert returned home alive and went on to start a family. And if Gilbert lived into old age, it points to Violet passing away much earlier since she was waiting for his return.

The Brooch

An elderly woman in the future possesses Violet’s signature brooch. This could suggest it was passed down through generations after Violet’s death.

However, the woman also recalls a memory of Gilbert fastening the brooch on a girl – likely Violet. So the memento could have been gifted to someone who knew Violet when she was alive.

Violet’s Letter to Gilbert

The movie revolves around a lost letter written by Violet to Gilbert near the end of her life. Its melancholic tone and reflection on her life’s purpose indicates Violet sensed she was nearing death.

Phrases like “my soul will always be with you” reinforce this sentiment. The letter encapsulates the feeling of a final goodbye.

Analyzing the Timeline – When Could Violet Have Died?

While we can’t determine exactly when Violet died based on the movie’s clues, we can make some logical guesses by piecing together the timeline:

  • The movie begins several years after the anime’s conclusion, with Violet still working as an Auto Memory Doll.
  • At some point near the end of her life, she writes a letter to Gilbert reflecting back on their relationship.
  • The future scenes take place approximately 60 years after the anime.
  • Violet’s absence is heavily implied here, along with the disappearance of Auto Memory Dolls.
  • Gilbert’s grandson Aidan appears as a young boy, meaning Gilbert likely started a family sometime after returning from the war.

Based on these points, Violet seems to have passed away years before the movie’s future era when she was elderly, possibly in her 60s or 70s. The war took place when she was a teenager, and she needed time to establish herself as an Auto Memory Doll and then write the poignant letter.

The most logical conclusion is that Violet died of old age at some point between the anime’s conclusion and the movie’s future era.

Also Read:

Digging Deeper – Symbolic Hints At Violet’s Death

Beyond the surface clues, some fans believe the movie contains metaphorical signs that Violet passed away:

The Ghostly Apparitions

Violet repeatedly sees glimpses of a ghostly figure that resembles herself as a child. These apparitions are likely meant to represent her childhood innocence that was lost in the war.

Some interpret the ghosts as Violet’s nostalgia for her past as death approaches. The spirits disappear as she finds closure.

Letting Go of Gilbert

A key element of Violet’s growth is learning to let go of her obsession with Gilbert. Through writing the letter, she realizes that while she’ll always love Gilbert, she must focus on giving purpose to her own life.

This journey to prioritize her own fulfillment over waiting for Gilbert’s return could be seen as Violet preparing for death.

Violet’s Vision of Gilbert

In the anime series, Violet imagines seeing Gilbert waiting for her at a train station. This vision happens after Gilbert is reported dead, and Violet clings to the belief he’ll return.

The train station scene could represent Violet entering the afterlife and finally reuniting with her lost love.

Putting the Pieces Together – Is Violet Truly Dead?

While these symbolic touches are open to interpretation, combined with the concrete clues, they strongly indicate Violet passed away long before the movie’s future era. The film takes an elegiac tone looking back on Violet’s life after she’s gone.

But a tiny bit of ambiguity remains. Some believe the future timeline represents:

  • Violet retreating from public life but still being alive.
  • Violet faking her death and assuming a new identity.
  • An alternate universe where Violet died young.

Ultimately, there is no definitive answer. But the weight of evidence strongly implies Violet died of natural causes at an old age, finally concluding her emotional journey. Her presence haunts the story as those left behind recall her profound impact on their lives.

Also Read:

The Meaning Behind Violet’s Fate

While Violet’s premature death would be tragic, her passing from old age allows for a bittersweet but meaningful ending. Here are some of the thematic implications if Violet died as an elderly woman:

She Found Peace and Purpose

After a traumatic childhood as a soldier, Violet overcame her pain and found fulfillment in bringing joy to others. Her letter to Gilbert reflects a sense of closure and acceptance of her life’s meaning.

Even if she never saw Gilbert again, she found inner peace. Her death was likely serene.

Her Memory Lives On

Violet left a lasting legacy. The people she touched still remember her decades later. She forged deep bonds that endured beyond her life.

In a sense, Violet achieved her goal of living on in others’ memories. Her death was not the end of her impact.

Her Values Endured

Ideals like empathy and understanding outlasted Violet. The future society still cherishes emotion and human connection, seen through examples like Aidan’s bond with his friends.

Violet’s work to spread awareness of these values created ripples beyond her time. She helped shape society for the better.

So while Violet’s death is sad, the implications elevate it to represent a meaningful conclusion reflecting her growth and lasting influence. For fans, it provides consolation and hope.

Conclusion: A Bittersweet Ending Reflecting Violet’s Journey

The melancholy ending of Violet Evergarden leaves much open to interpretation. But the weight of evidence points to Violet passing away from old age sometime before the movie’s future era, likely in her advanced years.

It’s a bittersweet conclusion that sees Violet make peace with her past trauma, find fulfillment in bringing people together through understanding, and leave a permanent mark on society.

Rather than a tragedy, the hints of Violet’s natural death give her story poignant meaning. She represents how even after we’re gone, our values and connections can endure. Violet remains alive in the hearts of those she touched.

So while we may long for a definitive answer, the ambiguity surrounding her fate allows Violet to live on as an eternal symbol of empathy. Her presence lingers as a ghostly but hopeful reminder of the light we can bring to the world

Also Read:

Meghan

The Editorial Team at AnswerCatch.com brings you insightful and accurate content on a wide range of topics. Our diverse team of talented writers is passionate about providing you with the best possible reading experience.