Do I Support Sigurd’s Judgment?

Sigurd, also known as Sigurd Snake-in-the-Eye, is an important character in the video game Assassin’s Creed Valhalla. In one particular quest called “Blame and Sail,” the player is presented with a choice to either support or reject Sigurd’s judgment in resolving a dispute. This choice carries weight, as it impacts the game’s storyline and which ending the player will achieve. So should the player support Sigurd’s judgment? Let’s explore this topic in depth.

What Happens in the “Blame and Sail” Quest?

During the quest “Blame and Sail,” the Viking clan arrives at a town where two residents – Gudrun and her son Holger – are engaged in a bitter dispute. Gudrun accuses Holger of stealing and selling her prized family heirloom, a golden ornament. However, Holger insists he is innocent and that the ornament was stolen by bandits.

As an outsider drawn into the conflict, the player must hear both sides and then decide who is telling the truth. But shortly after you make your choice, Sigurd intervenes and renders his own judgment on the matter.

He sides with Holger, stating the bandits are the real culprits. Sigurd then retrieves Gudrun’s ornament from the bandits and returns it to her. This enrages Gudrun, who adamantly believes her son is guilty despite Sigurd’s actions.

At this point, the player is given a dialogue choice – to either support Sigurd’s judgment or reject it and stand by your original decision.

Why Sigurd’s Judgment Matters for the True Ending

Supporting or rejecting Sigurd’s verdict is pivotal because it impacts which ending you’ll receive in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla.

The game has two main endings:

The “good” ending – Where Sigurd and Eivor’s friendship remains strong, and they reunite in the end.
The “bad” ending – Where Sigurd abandons Eivor, their bond breaks, and he is seen alone at the end.

To achieve the good ending, Eivor must maintain a high level of trust and support for Sigurd. Backing Sigurd’s judgment in the Holger and Gudrun dispute is one of the key moments that builds this trust.

If Eivor rejects Sigurd’s decision and scolds him, it will damage their friendship and make the bad ending more likely. But supporting Sigurd, even if you disagree with him, shows loyalty and ultimately keeps him as an ally to Eivor.

For those seeking the ideal conclusion and to maintain Eivor and Sigurd’s camaraderie, the recommended choice is to back Sigurd during this quest.

Why Might Someone Disagree with Sigurd’s Judgment?

While supporting Sigurd may seem like the clear option, there are reasons why a player may reject his verdict from a role-playing perspective.

Eivor Did Her Own Investigation

As the mediator in the Holger-Gudrun affair, Eivor takes time to hear both sides and weigh the evidence before deciding. She may feel that her judgment is fair and justified.

If Eivor is confident in her conclusion, she may be unwilling to abandon it simply because Sigurd decrees otherwise. She may feel strongly about standing up for what she believes is right.

Sigurd Oversteps His Bounds

When Sigurd interrupts and overrides Eivor’s decision, some may see it as him arrogantly asserting his authority. He makes a unilateral judgment without consulting Eivor first.

Eivor may resent Sigurd’s assumption that his word is law. She may desire him to show more respect for her perspective before intervening.

Gudrun Deserves Justice

Even after returning the ornament, Sigurd dismisses Gudrun’s outrage and refuses to punish Holger. For Eivor, Gudrun’s pain may warrant further investigation rather than ignoring her pleas.

Eivor could doubt Holger’s innocence and feel he manipulated Sigurd. Supporting Gudrun’s call for justice could be seen as the moral choice.

Why It’s Best to Back Sigurd Despite Disagreements

While Eivor may have reservations about Sigurd’s actions, there are compelling reasons to stand by him when directly asked:

It Preserves Eivor and Sigurd’s Bond

Even if his methods were flawed, Sigurd’s intent was to solve the dispute justly. Openly rejecting him would only breed resentment. Supporting him shows understanding and maintains unity.

Their fates are intertwined – Eivor’s future relies on having Sigurd as an ally against foes like King Aelfred. Their relationship is not worth jeopardizing over one disagreement.

Sigurd Has More Experience

Sigurd is older and more familiar with the complexities of clan politics and judgment. He likely sees angles Eivor doesn’t grasp as a younger, newer drengr.

While Eivor is still learning, Sigurd’s extra wisdom and perspective gives him the edge in adjudicating tricky conflicts. Trusting his judgment demonstrates Eivor’s respect.

Holger’s Guilt is Ambiguous

The truth around the stolen ornament is murky. While Gudrun seems certain of Holger’s guilt, concrete evidence is lacking.

Since Holger’s culpability is ambiguous, he deserves the benefit of the doubt. Eivor can respect Sigurd’s leniency toward the potentially innocent party.

Sigurd Went the Extra Mile

Not only did Sigurd declare Holger innocent, but he took steps to return Gudrun’s heirloom when he could have ignored the issue.

This shows he cared about justice for both sides – Gudrun and Holger. Backing Sigurd’s judgment acknowledges his efforts to satisfy all involved.

Key Takeaways – Supporting Sigurd is Recommended

In Assassin’s Creed Valhalla, supporting Sigurd during the “Blame and Sail” quest is pivotal for achieving the best ending.
Rejecting Sigurd’s judgment damages his bond with Eivor, while backing him preserves their alliance.
Players may disagree with Sigurd’s actions for various reasons. But overlooking disagreements to support Sigurd is wisest.
It maintains Eivor and Sigurd’s friendship, recognizes his experience, gives Holger the benefit of doubt, and appreciates Sigurd’s conflict resolution efforts.

So in summary – yes, it is recommended to back Sigurd’s judgment in this quest, even if you personally favor a different outcome. The rewards of Sigurd’s ongoing companionship and loyalty outweigh adhering to Eivor’s pride. Their fates are interwoven, and keeping Sigurd as a friend ensures the optimal conclusion.

Also Read:

Editorial Team

The Editorial Team at AnswerCatch.com brings you insightful and accurate content on a wide range of topics. Our diverse team of talented writers is passionate about providing you with the best possible reading experience.